A single ballot box served Zeytinli at the 2023 parliamentary election, with 162 registered voters; that places it 10th among the 14 localities of Gökçeada.
124 people voted at that election. CHP took the most votes with 42; AK Parti followed with 21. CHP's share here is 3.5 points above the district average. In the presidential runoff, 74 of 118 valid votes went to Kemal Kılıçdaroğlu — 2.3 points above the district average. At the 2017 referendum 48 of 78 valid votes were 'yes' — 23.0 points above the district average.
The electorate grew from 93 registered voters in 2011 to 162 in 2023 — a change of about 74 percent. The tightest race came at the 2015 parliamentary election: AK Parti took 35 votes to Yeşil Sol Parti's 25 — a margin of just 10 votes. At the 2023 parliamentary election 12 of 124 ballots cast were ruled invalid (9.7%), well above the district average. Turnout at the 2023 parliamentary election was 76.5%, 7.9 points below the district average.