With 60 voters on the roll at the 2023 parliamentary election, Karakaya stands 42nd among the 45 localities of Bayat, and its votes were cast at one ballot box.
53 people voted at that election. AK Parti took the most votes with 43; MHP followed with 4. AK Parti's share here is 29.4 points above the district average. In the presidential runoff, 51 of 54 valid votes went to Recep Tayyip Erdoğan — 14.1 points above the district average. At the 2017 referendum 78 of 79 valid votes were 'yes' — 16.5 points above the district average.
At the 2024 local election the neighborhood went to Yeniden Refah with 21 votes, while Bayat as a whole was won by AK Parti. Turnout at the 2024 local election was 79.1%, 6.4 points below the district average. The electorate shrank from 128 registered voters in 2011 to 60 in 2023 — a change of about 53 percent. The tightest race came at the 2024 local election: Yeniden Refah took 21 votes to AK Parti's 14 — a margin of just 7 votes.