A single ballot box served Karakaya at the 2023 parliamentary election, with 72 registered voters; that places it 80th among the 132 localities of Yıldızeli.
The neighborhood parts ways with the district as a whole. At the 2023 parliamentary election it went to CHP with 66 votes, while across Yıldızeli the leading party was AK Parti, with CHP here running 77.2 points above its district average. In the presidential runoff, 69 of 73 valid votes went to Kemal Kılıçdaroğlu — 74.0 points above the district average. At the 2017 referendum 75 of 77 valid votes were 'no' — 76.6 points above the district average.
At the 2024 local election the neighborhood went to CHP with 35 votes, while Yıldızeli as a whole was won by AK Parti. The picture has not changed since 2009: CHP has finished first in all of the last 9 elections. The electorate shrank from 103 registered voters in 2011 to 72 in 2023 — a change of about 30 percent. Turnout at the 2024 local election was 56.3%, 24.2 points below the district average.